CiNii Researchの本公開について

殺すことと死ぬにまかせることの間 : 道徳的差異と対称性について

書誌事項

タイトル別名
  • Between killing and letting die: its moral difference and “the moral symmetry”

この論文をさがす

抄録

type:紀要論文

In this paper, I discuss whether there are some moral differences between killing and letting die. Based on “the moral equivalence(Rachels)” or “the moral symmetry principle(Tooley)”, Rachels and \Tooley argue that there is no moral difference between killing and letting die. They thereby conclude that there is no moral difference between active euthanasia and passive euthanasia, and that active \euthanasia is also morally acceptable.\I argue two points. First, they give counterexamples for a moral principle “All killings are morally wrong.” This doesn.t justify individual actions such as giving lethal injection, withholding life \support treatment. Their claims don.t support individual actions in actual clinical practices. Second, I argue about a relationship between “the moral symmetry principle” and other moral principles. When \we evaluate an action using a moral principle, it is not always the case that “the moral symmetry principle” by itself takes precedence over other moral principles. To support the idea, some additional \justification is required to “the moral symmetry principle” used in case of euthanasia. Based on these points, I conclude that their attempts to argue for active euthanasia don.t succeed.

収録刊行物

  • 人間文化創成科学論叢

    人間文化創成科学論叢 16 69-76, 2014-03-31

    お茶の水女子大学大学院人間文化創成科学研究科

被引用文献 (0)

もっと見る

参考文献 (0)

もっと見る

関連論文

もっと見る

関連研究データ

もっと見る

関連図書・雑誌

もっと見る

関連博士論文

もっと見る

関連プロジェクト

もっと見る

関連その他成果物

もっと見る

詳細情報

ページトップへ