Testing the Fidelity of Simulations of Black Hole–Galaxy Coevolution at z ∼ 1.5 with Observations

<jats:title>Abstract</jats:title> <jats:p>We examine the scaling relations between the mass of a supermassive black hole (SMBH) and its host galaxy properties at 1.2 < <jats:italic>z</jats:italic> <1.7 using both observational data and simulations. Recent measurements of 32 X-ray-selected, broad-line active galactic nuclei (AGNs) are compared with two independent state-of-the-art efforts, including the hydrodynamic simulation <jats:monospace>MassiveBlackII</jats:monospace> (<jats:monospace>MBII</jats:monospace>) and a semianalytic model (<jats:monospace>SAM</jats:monospace>). After applying an observational selection function to the simulations, we find that both <jats:monospace>MBII</jats:monospace> and <jats:monospace>SAM</jats:monospace> agree well with the data, in terms of the central distribution. However, the dispersion in the mass ratio between black hole mass and stellar mass is significantly more consistent with the <jats:monospace>MBII</jats:monospace> prediction (∼0.3 dex) than with the <jats:monospace>SAM</jats:monospace> (∼0.7 dex), even when accounting for observational uncertainties. Hence, our observations can distinguish between the different recipes adopted in the models. The mass relations in the <jats:monospace>MBII</jats:monospace> are highly dependent on AGN feedback, while the relations in the <jats:monospace>SAM</jats:monospace> are more sensitive to galaxy-merger events triggering nuclear activity. Moreover, the intrinsic scatter in the mass ratio of our high-<jats:italic>z</jats:italic> sample is comparable with that observed in the local sample, all but ruling out the proposed scenario that the correlations are purely stochastic in nature arising from some sort of cosmic central limit theorem. Our results support the hypothesis of AGN feedback being responsible for a causal link between the SMBH and its host galaxy, resulting in a tight correlation between their respective masses.</jats:p>