Comparative Clinical Trial of HBK and Amikacin (AMK) in the Treatment of Respiratory Infections

  • HARA Kohei
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • SAITO Atsushi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • YAMAGUCHI Keizo
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • SHIGENO Yoshiteru
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • TAIRA Kazushige
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • ODA Toshiro
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • HAYASHI Toshiaki
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • TOMITA Hiroshi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • MASUYAMA Yasuharu
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Nagasaki University School of Medicineand Related Hospital
  • SAITO Akira
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • TOMIZAWA Masumi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • NAKAYAMA Ichiro
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • ABE Morikuni
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • MATSUHASHI Shosei
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • ISHIKAWA Kiyofumi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • UJIIE Akira
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicineand Releated Hospital
  • NAKABAYASHI Takehito
    Respiratory Division, National Sapporo Hospital
  • KOROKU Tetsuji
    Respiratory Division, National Sapporo Hospital
  • HIRAGA Yohmei
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Sapporo Hospital of Japanese National Railway
  • KIKUCHI Kohki
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Sapporo Hospital of Japanese National Railway
  • YAMAMOTO Asako
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Sapporo Hospital of Japanese National Railway
  • TAKEBE Kazuo
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • OKAMOTO Katsuhiro
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • SAGARA Morio
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • TAMURA Toyokazu
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • ENDO Katsumi
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • IRIE Tatsuro
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • UEHARA Osamu
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Hirosaki University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • TAMURA Masao
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Iwate Medical University
  • ITO Takashi
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Iwate Medical University
  • OBARA Kazuo
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Iwate Medical University
  • MIYAMOTO Shinya
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Iwate Medical University
  • KANAZAWA Tomohiro
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Akita University School of Medicine
  • TAKAHASHI Hiroshi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Akita University School of Medicine
  • 三浦 一樹
    秋田大学第2内科
  • KUROKAWA Hirokazu
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Akita University School of Medicine
  • YASUI Shoji
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • TAKAHASHI Keiji
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • SATO Shinobu
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • IKEDA Hideki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • NAKAMURA Hidenori
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • YASUMURA Seiji
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • IGARASHI Kohichi
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • HOSHI Hikaru
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • YAKUWA Sunao
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yamagata University School of Medicine
  • TAKISHIMA Tamotsu
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Tohoku University School of Medicine
  • IDA Shiroh
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Tohoku University School of Medicine
  • KONNO Kiyoshi
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • OIZUMI Kotaro
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • AONUMA Seiichi
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • WATANABE Akira
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • NAGAI Kosaku
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • SATO Kazuo
    Department of Internal Medicine, The Research Institute for Chest Diseases and Cancer, Tohoku University and Related Hospital
  • HAYASHI Izumi
    Division of Respiratory Diseases, Iwaki Kyoritsu General Hospital
  • KATSU Masataka
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kasumigaura National Hospital Department of Internal Medicine, Jiseikai Hospital
  • KAWAI Mieko
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kasumigaura National Hospital Department of Internal Medicine, Jiseikai Hospital
  • OGIWARA Koji
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kasumigaura National Hospital Department of Internal Medicine, Jiseikai Hospital
  • KAWAI Takeshi
    Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Keio University
  • AJISAWA Atsushi
    Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Keio University
  • SATO Shigeaki
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, The Jikei University School of Medicine
  • ISHIKAWA Kazuhito
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, The Jikei University School of Medicine
  • MIYAHARA Tadashi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, The Jikei University School of Medicine
  • IKEMOTO Hideo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Juntendo University School of Medicine
  • WATANABE Kazuyoshi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Juntendo University School of Medicine
  • ISONUMA Hiroshi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Juntendo University School of Medicine
  • KOBAYASHI Hiroyuki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kyorin University School of Medicine
  • KAWAI Shin
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kyorin University School of Medicine
  • YOSHIDA Masahiko
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kyorin University School of Medicine
  • KUNII Otohiko
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Teikyo University School of Medicine
  • MASHIMO Keimei
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tokyo Koseinenkin Hospital
  • YAMANE Yoshiji
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tokyo Koseinenkin Hospital
  • UKAI Tetsuro
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tokyo Koseinenkin Hospital
  • KOYAMA Masaru
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tokyo Kyosai Hospital
  • IIJIMA Fukuo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tokyo Kyosai Hospital
  • KABE Junzaburo
    Department of Chest Medicine, National Medical Center Hospital
  • ISHIBASHI Hiroyoshi
    Department of Chest Medicine, National Medical Center Hospital
  • UNO Yuko
    Department of Chest Medicine, National Medical Center Hospital
  • TANIMOTO Hiroichi
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • CHONABAYASHI Naohiko
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • NAKAMORI Yoshitaka
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • YOSHIMURA Kunihiko
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • NAKATANI Tatsuo
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • NAKATA Koichiro
    Chest Clinic, Toranomon Hospital
  • MASUDA Gohta
    Department of Infectious Diseases, Tokyo Metropolitan Komagome Hospital
  • NEGISHI Masayoshi
    Department of Infectious Diseases, Tokyo Metropolitan Komagome Hospital
  • YOUNG Chenden
    Department of Infectious Diseases, Tokyo Metropolitan Komagome Hospital
  • HIGASHI Fuyuhiko
    Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital of Tokyo Electric Power Co., Inc.
  • FUNATSU Yuzo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital of Tokyo Electric Power Co., Inc.
  • FUJIMORI Ippei
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Municipal Hospital
  • KOBAYASHI Yoshio
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Municipal Hospital
  • OKUBO Takao
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama City University School of Medicine
  • ITO Akira
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama City University School of Medicine
  • SANO Fumihiko
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama City University School of Medicine
  • MATSUZAKI Michio
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama City University School of Medicine
  • ASADA Yuko
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama City University School of Medicine
  • ODAGIRI Shigeki
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • SUZUKI Kaneo
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • MUROHASHI Kou
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • FUKUDA Tsutomu
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • YOSHIIKE Yasuhiro
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • MATSUMURA Masanori
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • KIUCHI Mitsuyo
    Department of Respiratory Disease, Kanagawa Prefectural Nagahama Hospital
  • MATSUMOTO Fumio
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kanagawa Prefecture Midwives and Nurses Training School Hospital
  • FUKAYA Kazufuto
    Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama Teishin Hospital
  • TAKIGAMI Tadashi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama Seamen's Insurance Hospital
  • SHODA Masataka
    Department of Internal Medicine, Yokohama Seamen's Insurance Hospital
  • ARAKAWA Masaaki
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Niigata University School of Medicine
  • WADA Kohichi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Niigata University School of Medicine
  • SEKINE Osamu
    Department of Internal Medicine, Shinrakuen Hospital
  • AOKI Nobuki
    Department of Internal Medicine, Shinrakuen Hospital
  • OYAMA Kaoru
    Department of Internal Medicine, Toyama Prefectural Center Hospital
  • NAKAMURA Shinobu
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Kanazawa University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • NAKAMURA Takeshi
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Kanazawa University School of Medicine and Related Hospital
  • YAMAMOTO Toshiyuki
    Department of Internal Medicine, Nagoya Koseiin Geriatric Hospital
  • SUZUKI Kanzo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Nagoya Koseiin Geriatric Hospital
  • ADACHI Akira
    Department of Internal Medicine, Nagoya Koseiin Geriatric Hospital
  • KUZE Fumiyuki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • NAKANISHI Michiyasu
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • KURASAWA Takuya
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • KUBO Yoshiro
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • NISHIYAMA Hideki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • IKEDA Nobuaki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • INABA Norio
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • KAGIOKA Akira
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Chest Disease Research Institute, Kyoto University and Related Hospital
  • MIKI Fumio
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • IKUNO Yoshiyasu
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • INOUE Eiji
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • MURATA Akihito
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • TANIZAWA Shin-ichi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • SAKAMOTO Kazuo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • TAKAMATSU Kenji
    Department of Internal Medicine, Tane General Hospital and Izumi Municipal Hospital
  • SOEJIMA Rinzo
    Department of Respiratory Diseases of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Medical School
  • NIKI Yoshihito
    Department of Respiratory Diseases of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Medical School
  • HINO Jiro
    Department of Respiratory Diseases of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Medical School
  • NAKAGAWA Yoshihisa
    Department of Respiratory Diseases of Internal Medicine, Kawasaki Medical School
  • NISHIMOTO Yukio
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hiroshima University School of Medicine
  • YAMAKIDO Michio
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hiroshima University School of Medicine
  • KAMITSUNA Akimitsu
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hiroshima University School of Medicine
  • HASEGAWA Kenji
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Hiroshima University School of Medicine
  • KURIMURA Osamu
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kure National Hospital
  • SASAKI Hideo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kure National Hospital
  • FUKUHARA Hirofumi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Kure National Hospital
  • TAMURA Masakazu
    The Third Department of Internal Medicine, Tokushima University School of Medicine
  • TSUBURA Eiro
    Department of Internal Medicine, The National Toneyama Chest Hospital
  • FUKUYAMA Koichi
    Department of Internal Medicine, The National Toneyama Chest Hospital
  • MORIMOTO Tadaaki
    Department of Internal Medicine, The National Toneyama Chest Hospital
  • SAWAE Yoshiro
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Kyushu University
  • NAGANO Hitoshi
    Department of Clinical Research, National Minamifukuoka Chest Hospital
  • YOKOTA Takeo
    Department of Clinical Research, National Minamifukuoka Chest Hospital
  • YOKOTA Kinji
    Department of Clinical Research, National Minamifukuoka Chest Hospital
  • SHINODA Atsushi
    Department of Internal Medicine, National Ohmuta Hospital
  • ISHIBASHI Tsuneo
    Department of Internal Medicine, National Ohmuta Hospital
  • TAKAMOTO Masahiro
    Department of Internal Medicine, National Ohmuta Hospital
  • HARADA Yasuko
    Department of Internal Medicine, National Ohmuta Hospital
  • KITAHARA Yoshinari
    Department of Internal Medicine, National Ohmuta Hospital
  • KAJI Masaro
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kurume University School of Medicine
  • ICHIKAWA Yoichiro
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kurume University School of Medicine
  • NASU Masaru
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Medical College of Oita
  • GOTO Jun
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Medical College of Oita
  • GOTO Yoichiro
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Medical College of Oita
  • YAMAZAKI Hitoshi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Medical College of Oita
  • TASHIRO Takayoshi
    The Second Department of Internal Medicine, Medical College of Oita
  • MATSUMOTO Keizo
    Department of Internal Medicine, Institute for Tropical Medicine, Nagasaki University and Related Hospital
  • OHISHI Kazunori
    Department of Internal Medicine, Institute for Tropical Medicine, Nagasaki University and Related Hospital
  • IZUMIKAWA Kinichi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • KOTEDA Tsunetoshi
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • NAKAJIMA Manabu
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • KOMATSU Kohei
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • NAKATA Masaya
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • SENJU Reiko
    Department of Internal Medicine, Sasebo Municipal Hospital
  • ANDO Masayuki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kumamoto University School of Medicine
  • SUGA Moritaka
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kumamoto University School of Medicine
  • NIIBORI Toshifumi
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kumamoto University School of Medicine
  • NAKAGAWA Toshiyuki
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kumamoto University School of Medicine
  • YOSHIDA Kazuko
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Kumamoto University School of Medicine
  • KOBARI Kazumine
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Ryukyu University School of Medicine
  • NAKATOMI Masao
    The First Department of Internal Medicine, Ryukyu University School of Medicine
  • TANAKA Tsuneo
    Faculty of Medicine, University of Tokyo

Bibliographic Information

Other Title
  • 呼吸器感染症に対するHBKとAmikacinの薬効比較成績
  • 呼吸器感染症に対するHBKとAmiracinの薬効比較成績
  • コキュウキ カンセンショウ ニ タイスル HBK ト Amiracin ノ ヤッコウ ヒカク セイセキ

Search this article

Abstract

The clinical efficacy and safety of HBK were compaired with those of amikacin (AMK) in 230 patients with respiratory infections (pneumonia or lung abscess, chronic respiratory tract infections) by means of a double-blind study at 50 institutions in Japan. Patients over 15 years old with apparent clinical signs and symptoms were administered HBK or AMK intramuscularly b. i. d. for 14 days with a daily dose of 200 mg (pot.) of HBK or 400 mg (pot.) of AMK. The parameters assessed were clinical efficacy, rate of improvement of clinical signs and symptoms, bacteriological response, appearance of side effect, abnormal laboratory findings and clinical usefulness.<BR>Clinical efficacy was analysed statistically in 199 patients (100 administered HBK, 99 administered AMK), but 31 patients out of a total of 230 patients were excluded. Side effects were also anlaysed in 213 patients (HBK: 108, AMK: 105) in whom judgement was possible.<BR>1. On the basis of committee judgement, the overall clinical efficacy rate for pneumonia or lungabscess was 63.2% for HBK and 69.4% for AMK. Those for chronic respiratory tract infections were 46.5% for HBK and 60.0% for AMK. No significant difference was observed between the two drug groups.<BR>In the evaluation of clinical efficacy by the doctor, the overall efficacy ratesinpneumonia or lung abscess cases were 70.4% for HBK and 61.2% for AMK. Those for chronic respiratory tract infections were 55.8% for HBK and 62.0% for AMK. No significant difference was observed between the two drug groups.<BR>2. With respect to the rate of improvement of clinical signs and symptoms, the HBKgroup was superior to the AMK group in the improvement of sputum volume five days after treatment (p<0.05) in patients with pneumonia or lung abscess. In patients with chronic respiratory tract infections, the AMK group was superior to the HBK group in the improvement of body temperature and CRPseven days after treatment (p<0.05).<BR>3. The bacteriological eradication rate of causative organisms was 38.3% out of 51 patients treated with HBK and 37.5% out of 50 treated with AMK. There was no significant differencebetween the two groups.<BR>4. Some side effects were observed in 10 patients out of 108 in the HBK group, butnone were observed in the AMK group. The HBK group displayed a significantly higher rate of side effects than the AMK group. Abnormal laboratory findings were observed at the rate of 23.4% forHBK and 20.0% for AMK, without significant differences between the two groups.<BR>5. Regarding usefulness as judged by committee members, the respective rate for the HBK group and AMK group were 53.8% and 64.6%. Usefulness, as judged by the doctor in charge, was 63.0% for the HBK group and 63.3% for the AMK group. These assessments showed no significantdifferences between the two groups.<BR>From the above results, it was concluded that HBK is as equally useful as AMK for the drug treatment of respiratory infections.

Journal

  • Kansenshogaku Zasshi

    Kansenshogaku Zasshi 61 (1), 22-53, 1987

    The Japanese Association for Infectious Diseases

Details 詳細情報について

Report a problem

Back to top