[Updated on Apr. 18] Integration of CiNii Articles into CiNii Research

Effects of trust on sanctioning behavior and evaluating self-fairness : Warning and vengeance


Bibliographic Information

Other Title
  • サンクション行動および公正さの認知における信頼の効果 : 戒めと報復
  • サンクション コウドウ オヨビ コウセイサ ノ ニンチ ニ オケル シンライ ノ コウカ イマシメ ト ホウフク

Search this article


We investigated how differently people punish a free-rider in three experiments. Experiment 1 was conducted to examine how individual levels of trust and self-fairness influence their punishing behavior in a 5-person social dilemma. The results showed that trustful and unfair people, as well as distrustful and fair people, punish a free-rider more. To account for these results, we carried out a vignette-type study in Experiment 2, in which participants rated how likely they were to engage in a variety of punishing behaviors that typically happen in the real world. A factor analysis indicated that people usually assign two different types of meanings to punishing behaviors. One is "Vengeance," which unfair people, regardless of their levels of trust, tend to inflict; the other is "Warning," which tends to be favored by fair people. The results of Experiment 3, another vignette study, showed that observers also consider Vengeance as unfair and Warning fair. These findings imply that participants assigned one of the two meanings to their punishments in Experiment 1 depending on their levels of trust.


Citations (0)*help

See more


See more

Related Articles

See more

Related Data

See more

Related Books

See more

Related Dissertations

See more

Related Projects

See more

Related Products

See more


Report a problem

Back to top