グライス理論における協調原理と格率一般との論理的関係

DOI Web Site 1 Citations

Bibliographic Information

Other Title
  • グライス リロン ニ オケル キョウチョウ ゲンリ ト カクリツ イッパン ト ノ ロンリテキ カンケイ

Search this article

Description

In this paper, I have explicated the logical relation between the Maxims and the Cooperative Principle (CP, hereafter) as stipulated in Grice's theory of conversation. First, by showing the existence of cases where the CP is followed but the relevant maxim is not, I have shown that those maxims are logically independent from the CP. Second, the Maxim of Relation (MR, hereafter) has been misleadingly conceived to provide the basic notion of "relevance" for the theory of conversation. But, when a speaker, while deviating from the MR, or failing to "be relevant" literally, still follow the context in some sense or other, it must be another kind of "relevance" that is highlighted. That kind of "relevance" in conversation is required by the CP. I have called this kind of relevance CONNECTEDNESS as opposed to the RELEVANCE as required by the MR.

Journal

  • Kagaku tetsugaku

    Kagaku tetsugaku 34 (2), 101-116, 2001

    The Philosophy of Science Society, Japan

Citations (1)*help

See more

Details 詳細情報について

Report a problem

Back to top