Policy evidence on an elementary school English education program

DOI Web Site

Bibliographic Information

Other Title
  • 小学校英語に関する政策的エビデンス
  • 小学校英語に関する政策的エビデンス : 子どもの英語力・態度は向上したのか?
  • ショウガッコウ エイゴ ニ カンスル セイサクテキ エビデンス : コドモ ノ エイゴリョク ・ タイド ワ コウジョウ シタ ノ カ?
  • Has the program improved children’s English skills and other attitudes?
  • 子どもの英語力・態度は向上したのか？

Search this article

Description

The purpose of this paper is to examine the effectiveness of elementary school English education programs (ESEEP) first implemented in the 2000s. I examined this issue from an evidence-based policy approach, rather than a second language acquisition perspective. In other words, I employed a research design that ensured internal validity and external validity, both of which are a prerequisite for obtaining reliable evidence although they have generally been disregarded by the previous work on ESEEP. Based on this design, I examined whether the implementation of ESEEP has achieved its stated goals, by analyzing questionnaire data from nationally representative 2,967 junior high school students (provided by an open data archive). Based on structural equation modeling, I estimated causal effects of respondents’ ESEEP experience on their English language skills, intercultural awareness, and positive attitudes toward English learning. The result suggests that the ESEEP experience did not have any substantial impact. This result, I argue, can be considered as counter-evidence against the current policy reform on ESEEP, and thus suggest that the government, and pro-ESEEP researchers as well, should provide further evidence that indicates the effectiveness of ESEEP if they attempt to maintain the policy.

Journal

  • KATE Journal

    KATE Journal 32 (0), 57-70, 2018

    Kantokoshinetsu Association of Teachers of English

Related Projects

See more

Keywords

Details 詳細情報について

Report a problem

Back to top