コミュニケーションにおける引用可能性と教育的パフォーマンス

DOI HANDLE Web Site オープンアクセス
  • 土戸 敏彦
    九州大学大学院人間環境学研究院国際教育環境学講座 : 教授 : 現代教育思想論

書誌事項

タイトル別名
  • The quotability in communication and educational performance
  • コミュニケーション ニ オケル インヨウ カノウセイ ト キョウイクテキ パフォーマンス

この論文をさがす

説明

It is due to "contexts" that any communication is ultimately ambiguous. According to J.Derrida the problems concerning "context" should be considered in relation to written language (écriture) rather than spoken language, for every language basically contains the elements of written language. Écriture presupposes "death" of the reader and can accordingly sever its connection to context i.e. "wholeness of the present". This means that any message can be "quoted". According to J. L. Austin, in the performative utterances, if said by actor on the stage, in a poem, in soliloquy, language is used in ways "parasitic" upon its normal use, i.e. "unfelicitous". That is to say, they are "quoted". Based on this idea, J. Searle insisted that "felicitous" speech where "intention" and "expression" are in accord each other should be standard for the performatives. In opposition to it Derrida asserted that any performative is inevitably "unfelicitous" and involves "quotability". Deirrida called the frame of "intention" and "expression" itself into question. What the "transcendental jokability" as H. Nagai calls it means is that speaker can quote his own speech. This shows that the boundary between the original (before quotation) speech and parasitic (quoted) speech is ambiguous and that any performative already involves quotability. Nagai also stands on the frame of "intention" and "expression", but the contraposition of both is a kind of illusion. As a matter of fact "expression" produces "intention" in given contexts. It seems to be considered generally that common communications can be admitted to be "unserious" but as to education communication must be "serious" i.e. "intention" and "expression" accord each other. Is that right? Sending messages to learners, teachers should be aware that his messages can be quoted by himself. The teachers have and should have further messages which outreach the messages they are sending.

収録刊行物

キーワード

詳細情報 詳細情報について

問題の指摘

ページトップへ